Project

General

Profile

Statistics
| Branch: | Tag: | Revision:

gdp / doc / developer / gdp-rest-interface.html @ master

History | View | Annotate | Download (22.7 KB)

1
<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN">
2
<html>
3
  <head>
4
    <meta content="text/html; charset=UTF-8" http-equiv="content-type">
5
    <title>GDP REST Interface</title>
6
    <meta content="Eric Allman" name="author">
7
  </head>
8
  <body>
9
    <h1>RESTful Interface for the Global Data Plane</h1>
10
    Eric Allman, U.C. Berkeley Swarm Lab<br><br>Revision Notes:<br>
11
    Draft 8 2017-06-02, rpratt@berkeley.edu: GDP & GCL scope separation, API revisions.<br>
12
    <p>This document describes the RESTful interface to the Global Data Plane
13
      (GDP). Note that this is not part of the GDP itself, since that layer
14
      treats all records as opaque. This level adds simple key-value structure
15
      to the data for the convenience of users, and in some cases assumes the
16
      data is valid JSON text.</p>
17
    <h2>1 Introduction</h2>
18
    <p>This interface is a true RESTful interface, that is, it uses
19
      GET/POST/PUT/DELETE instead of overloading everything into
20
      GET. This implies that requests cannot be submitted using only
21
      an off the shelf web browser because browsers will only use POST
22
      methods in response to an HTML form.</p>
23
    <p>The data representation chosen is JSON, which is easier to build and
24
      parse than XML.&nbsp; <i>[[This should be expanded to include XML as
25
        specified by the Accept header.]]</i><br>
26
    </p>
27
    <p>All RESTful calls have the prefix "<code>/gdp/v1</code>" to allow
28
      overloading with other services and to allow multiple versions of the
29
      protocol to run simultaneously on one node.</p>
30
    <p>Objects in the dataplane are called GDP Channel-Logs (GCLs), representing
31
      their dual nature as both a communication channel and a storage log. GCLs
32
      are named with 256-bit values encoded in Base64url notation or as a
33
      user-meaningful text string, possibly including slashes, which is hashed
34
      using SHA-256 to produce an internal value.</p>
35
    <h2>2 Security</h2>
36
    <p>Everything stored in the GDP is supposed to be encrypted; however, this
37
      interface does not enforce this policy and treats all GDP data as though
38
      it were encoded in JSON; in particular, in some cases it may be
39
      encapsulated inside another JSON object. Data returned in response to a
40
      status request (e.g., for the number of records available) is always
41
      returned unencrypted as a JSON object.<br>
42
    </p>
43
    <p><i>A way around this assumption of JSON data content is to return all
44
        data as base64-encoded strings.&nbsp; However, this puts more work on
45
        the client.</i><br>
46
    </p>
47
    <p>Although the data portion of the GDP transaction may be
48
      encrypted, an HTTP request/response exchange is not, so it is
49
      highly recommended that clients authenticate and communicate
50
      with a RESTful server using HTTPS only. Depending on
51
      writer-platform capabilities, basic or htdigest client
52
      authentication within an encrypted session may be useful to gate
53
      resource consumption and log access within an organization's
54
      larger security perimeter.</p>
55
    <h2>3 Individual Operations</h2>
56
    <p>In general all GET calls must include "Accept: application/json".&nbsp; <i>Is
57
        this true?</i><br>
58
    </p>
59
    <p>The symbol &lt;gcl_name&gt; can be either a 43-character base64-encoded
60
      value or a string composed of characters legal in the path portion of a
61
      URL (including slashes), either of which is converted to a 256-bit
62
      location-independent GCL name.<br>
63
    </p>
64
    <p>The symbol &lt;gcl_id&gt; refers only to the base64-encoded name of a
65
      GCL.<br>
66
    </p>
67
    <p>In all cases, timestamps are in ISO 8601 format (<i>YYYY</i>-<i>MM</i>-<i>DD</i>T<i>HH</i>:<i>MM</i>:<i>SS</i>.<i>SSSSSSSSS</i>Z,
68

    
69

    
70
      including nanoseconds, and in UTC) possibly followed by a slash ("/") and
71
      a time accuracy in seconds; for example
72
      "2014-11-22T13:03:09.395023619/3.5" (you can read the slash as
73
      "&plusmn;").&nbsp; Record numbers may be as large as 2<sup>63</sup>
74
      &ndash; 1 (18,446,744,073,709,551,615). </p>
75
    <h3>Standard GCLs</h3>
76
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
77
    <h4>Name</h4>
78
    GET /gdp/v1/gcl &mdash; list all known GCLs <em>[</em><em><em>NOT
79
        IMPLEMENTED</em>; see Notes]</em><br>
80
    <h4>Request Body</h4>
81
    none<br>
82
    <h4>Response</h4>
83
    <p>200 OK<br>
84
    </p>
85
    <pre>    Content-Type: application/json; type=gdp/gcllist
86
<br>    [
87
        &lt;gcl_id&gt;,
88
        ...<br>    ]</pre>
89
    <p>401 Unauthorized<br>
90
    </p>
91
    <h4>Description</h4>
92
    <p>Returns a list of GCL names encoded as base64 strings.<br>
93
    </p>
94
    <p><i>[[Should include some way of limiting the number of values, e.g.,
95
        "?start=&lt;#&gt;&amp;max=&lt;#&gt;", since this could be a very large
96
        list.&nbsp; It would probably be more useful if we could include some
97
        query, e.g., only return GCLs where the metadata matches some pattern,
98
        but that would require a change in the GDP protocol itself.]]</i></p><h4>Notes</h4>
99
    <p>Not implemented at this time, and is unlikely to be implemented in this form in the future.&nbsp; This requires display of the global state of the GDP, which is likely to be immense.&nbsp; A possible alternative implementation would take a query that would be passed to a directory service.&nbsp;
100
      Returns 405 Method Not Allowed.<br>
101
    </p>
102
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
103
    <h4>Name</h4>
104
    GET /gdp/v1/gcl/&lt;gcl_name&gt; &mdash; list information known about
105
    specified GCL <em>[NOT IMPLEMENTED at this time]</em><br>
106
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
107
    none<br>
108
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
109
    <p>200 OK<br>
110
    </p>
111
    <pre>    Content-Type: application/json; type=gdp/gcldesc
112
<br>    {
113
            "gcl_id": &lt;gcl_id&gt;,<br>        "nrecs": &lt;integer&gt;,<br>        ...
114
    }</pre>
115
    <p>The gcl_id will be the internal name of the GCL.<br>
116
    </p>
117
    <p>401 Unauthorized</p>
118
    <p>404 Not Found<br>
119
    </p>
120
    <h4>Description</h4>
121
    <p>Returns information about the created GCL encoded as a JSON object.&nbsp;
122
      The information should at a minimum include the canonical name of the GCL
123
      and the number of records.&nbsp; When GCL metadata is present it should be
124
      returned as well.</p>
125
    <p> </p>
126
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
127
    <h4>Name</h4>
128
    <a id="POST-GCL">POST</a> /gdp/v1/gcl &mdash; Create a new GCL with a random name&nbsp;<br>
129
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
130
    <p>
131
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
132
<br>    {
133
      "external-name": null;
134
       <i><u>, optional gcl-create parameters</u></i>
135
    }</pre>
136
        <p>The <i><u>optional gcl-create parameters</u></i> are supplied
137
          as zero or more comma delimited JSON lines. For example:
138
          </p>
139
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
140
<br>    {
141
      "external-name": null,
142
      "-C": "creator_name@berkeley.edu"
143
    }</pre>
144
          <p>RESTful server supported parameter keys are "-C", "-h", "-k",
145
          "-b", "-c", and "-s", and should be paired with a parameter value
146
          which is valid for the selected parameter key. Consult the
147
          gcl-create documentation or man page for detailed parameter
148
          help. Metadata may be optionally specified, using the
149
          RESTful-unique "META" key, paired with a value which is a JSON
150
          array of one or more comma separated
151
          "&lt;metadataname&gt;=&lt;metadata&gt;" strings as array elements.
152
          </p>
153
        </p>
154
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
155
    <p> 201 Created<br>
156
    </p>
157
    <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
158
<br>    {
159
            "gcl_name": &lt;gcl_id&gt;,<br>        "gdplogd_name": &lt;gdplogd_name&gt;
160
    }</pre>
161
    <p>400 Bad Request<br>
162
    </p>
163
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
164
<br>    {
165
      "detail": &lt;detail&gt;
166
    }</pre>
167
    <p>409 Conflict<br>
168
    </p>
169
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
170
<br>    {
171
      "detail": "generated-name conflict on gdplogd server"
172
    }</pre>
173
    <p>500 Internal Server Error<br>
174
    </p>
175
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
176
<br>    {
177
      "detail": &lt;detail&gt;<br>      [, optional diagnostic key/value pairs]
178
    }</pre>
179
      <h4>Description</h4>
180
    <p>Creates a new GCL under an internally-assigned name and returns the
181
      information about that GCL in the same format as that delivered by the
182
      status query.</p><h4>Notes</h4><p>The plan is that GCLs will be created using a log creation service that will deal with resource allocation.&nbsp; This command is likely to be an interface to that service.<br>
183
    </p>
184
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
185
    <h4>Name</h4>
186
    <a id="PUT-GCL">PUT</a> /gdp/v1/gcl &mdash; Create a new GCL with a specified name&nbsp;<br>
187
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
188
    <p>
189
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
190
<br>    {
191
      "external-name": &lt;user_selected_name&gt;
192
       <i><u>, optional gcl-create parameters</u></i>
193
    }</pre>
194
        <p>The <i><u>optional gcl-create parameters</u></i> are supplied
195
          as zero or more comma delimited JSON lines. For example:
196
          </p>
197
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
198
<br>    {
199
      "external-name": "edu.berkeley.eecs.swarmlab.test.log00",
200
      "-C": "creator_name@berkeley.edu"
201
    }</pre>
202
          <p>RESTful server supported parameter keys are "-C", "-h", "-k",
203
          "-b", "-c", and "-s", and should be paired with a parameter value
204
          which is valid for the selected parameter key. Consult the
205
          gcl-create documentation or man page for detailed parameter
206
          help. Metadata may be optionally specified, using the
207
          RESTful-unique "META" key, paired with a value which is a JSON
208
          array of one or more comma separated
209
          "&lt;metadataname&gt;=&lt;metadata&gt;" strings as array elements.
210
          </p>
211
        </p>
212
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
213
    <p> 201 Created<br>
214
    </p>
215
    </p>
216
    <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
217
<br>    {
218
            "gcl_name": &lt;gcl_id&gt;,<br>        "gdplogd_name": &lt;gdplogd_name&gt;
219
    }</pre>
220
    <p>400 Bad Request<br>
221
    </p>
222
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
223
<br>    {
224
      "detail": &lt;detail&gt;
225
    }</pre>
226
    <p>409 Conflict<br>
227
    </p>
228
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
229
<br>    {
230
      "detail": "external-name already exists on gdplogd server"
231
    }</pre>
232
    <p>500 Internal Server Error<br>
233
    </p>
234
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
235
<br>    {
236
      "detail": &lt;detail&gt;<br>      [, optional diagnostic key/value pairs]
237
    }</pre>
238
      <h4>Description</h4>
239
    <p>Creates a new GCL under a user-assigned name and returns the
240
      information about the creation of that GCL, or reports a
241
      conflict if the name already exists.</p>
242
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
243
    <h4>Name</h4>
244
    DELETE /gdp/v1/gcl &mdash; delete a GCL <em>[NOT IMPLEMENTED; see Notes]</em><br>
245
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
246
    <p>
247
      <pre>    Content-Type: application/json;
248
<br>    {
249
      "external-name": &lt;user_selected_name&gt;
250
    }</pre>
251
    </p>
252
    <h4>Response</h4>
253
    <p>204 No Content</p>
254
    <p>401 Unauthorized</p>
255
    <p>404 Not Found<br>
256
    </p>
257
    <h4>Description</h4><h4>Notes</h4><p>Currently the GDP does not support log deletion.&nbsp; Until it does this will not be implemented.</p>
258
    <p><br>
259
    </p>
260
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
261
    <h4>Name</h4>
262
    <a id="POST-REC">POST</a> /gdp/v1/gcl/&lt;gcl_name&gt; &mdash; add a record to specified GCL<br>
263
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
264
    (Opaque data to be appended, but recommended to use JSON)<br>
265
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
266
    <p>201 Created<br>
267
    </p>
268
    <pre>    Content-Type: application/json; type=gdp/response<br><br>   &nbsp;{
269
            "gcl_id": &lt;gcl_id&gt;,
270
            "recno": &lt;integer&gt;,<br>        "timestamp": &lt;commit timestamp&gt;<br>        ...
271
    }</pre>
272
    <p>401 Unauthorized<br>
273
    </p>
274
    <p>404 Not Found<br>
275
    </p>
276
    <h4>Description</h4>
277
    <p>Adds a record to the named GCL.&nbsp; The information returned shows the
278
      GDP-assigned metadata associated with the new record.<br>
279
    </p>
280
    <p> </p>
281
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
282
    <h4>Name</h4>
283
    <a id="GET-REC">GET</a> /gdp/v1/gcl/&lt;gcl_name&gt;?recno=&lt;#&gt; &mdash; return a specified
284
    record<br>
285
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
286
    none<br>
287
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
288
    <p>200 OK<br>
289
    </p>
290
    <pre>    Content-Type: &lt;as specified as metadata during GCL creation&gt;
291
    GDP-Record-Number: &lt;recno&gt;<br>    GDP-Commit-Timestamp: &lt;timestamp&gt;<br><br>   &nbsp;&lt;opaque data as written by POST&gt;</pre>
292
    <p> </p>
293
    <p>404 Not Found<br>
294
    </p>
295
    <h4>Description</h4>
296
    <p>Returns the contents of the record indicated by <i>recno</i>.&nbsp; As a
297
      special case, if recno is the text "last" it returns the last (most
298
      recently written) record.<br>
299
    </p>
300
    <p>Note that the metadata is included in the response header, not in the
301
      data itself, in order to maintain the opacity of that data. <i>Question:
302
        should we move the metadata into the header for other commands as well
303
        to maintain symmetry?</i><br>
304
    </p>
305
    <p>This call is not orthogonal to the others because it does not assume that
306
      the data is application/json.<br>
307
    </p>
308
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
309
    <p> </p>
310
    <h4>Name</h4>
311
    GET /gdp/v1/gcl/&lt;gcl_name&gt;?recno=&lt;#&gt;&amp;nrecs=&lt;#&gt; &mdash;
312
    get a series of records<br>
313
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
314
    none<br>
315
    <h4>Response</h4>
316
    200 OK<br>
317
    <pre>    [<br>        {<br>            "recno": &lt;integer&gt;,<br>            "timestamp": &lt;timestamp&gt;,<br>            "value": &lt;record value&gt;<br>        },<br>        ...<br>    ]</pre>
318
    404 Not Found<br>
319
    <h4>Description</h4>
320
    <p>Returns a sequence of up to <i>nrecs</i> records starting from <i>recno</i>
321
      encoded as an array of JSON objects.&nbsp; If <i>nrecs</i> is zero, all
322
      data from <i>recno</i> to the end is returned.&nbsp; The <i>recno</i>
323
      parameter is optional and defaults to 1.</p>
324
    <p>The <var>nrecs</var> parameter is not implemented at this time.<br>
325
    </p>
326
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
327
    <h4>Name</h4>
328
    GET
329
    /gdp/v1/gcl/gcl_id?recno=&lt;#&gt;&amp;nrecs=&lt;#&gt;&amp;timeout=&lt;seconds&gt;
330

    
331

    
332

    
333

    
334
    &mdash; monitor a GCL<br>
335
    <h4>Request Data</h4>
336
    none<br>
337
    <h4>Response Data</h4>
338
    <p>200 OK<br>
339
    </p>
340
    <p>401 Unauthorized<br>
341
    </p>
342
    <p>404 Not Found<br>
343
    </p>
344
    <p>408 Request Timeout<br>
345
    </p>
346
    <h4>Description</h4>
347
    <p>If the indicated GCL does not exist, the GET returns immediately with a
348
      404 error code. Otherwise, if the indicated record number exists, the
349
      result is exactly the same as the previous case. If the indicated record
350
      number does not exist, this call waits for up to the indicated timeout for
351
      that record to appear; if it does, the record is returned in the usual
352
      way, otherwise it returns with a 408 Request Timeout response. If the
353
      starting record number is not specified, it starts from the beginning.</p><h4>Notes</h4>
354
    <p>The <var>nrecs</var> and <var>timeout</var> parameters are not
355
      implemented at this time.</p>
356
    <p><i>[[Perhaps this should not take recno and nrecs, and just return the
357
        next record that appears at the GCL.]]</i><br>
358
    </p>
359
    <p><i>[[There is some debate about whether this is the correct interface
360
        rather than falling back to a non-REST interface (such as WebSockets)
361
        for subscriptions. HTTP (and hence REST) isn&rsquo;t designed to handle
362
        spontaneous server to client messages.</i><i>]]</i><br>
363
    </p>
364
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
365
    <h4>Name</h4>
366
    GET /gdp/v1/post/gcl/&lt;gcl_name&gt;?&lt;arguments&gt; &mdash; add data to
367
    a GCL (<i><b>not REST compliant</b></i>)<br>
368
    <h4>Description</h4>
369
    <p>To be determined.&nbsp; Probably will create a JSON object including the
370
      specified arguments and append that to the GCL, unencrypted of course.<br>
371
    </p>
372
    <p> </p>
373
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
374
    <h3>Key-Value Store</h3>
375
    <p>The key-value store is implemented as a single GCL that must be formatted
376
      as unencrypted JSON data structured as a series of JSON objects.&nbsp; The
377
      "keys" are the field names in that top level object.&nbsp; When adding
378
      data to the KV store an arbitrary number of values may be sent in any one
379
      record.&nbsp; When retrieving data the key name is specified and the most
380
      recent value corresponding to that key is returned.</p>
381
    <p>The GCL used to implement is named "<code>swarm.rest.kvstore.gcl</code>".&nbsp;
382
      It may be overridden with the "<code>swarm.rest.kvstore.gclname</code>"
383
      administrative runtime parameter.</p>
384
    <p>Note that another way of implementing a KV store is to have an arbitrary
385
      GCL, the name of which represents the key, and just get the last (most
386
      recent) value to get the current value for that key.&nbsp; This trades off
387
      a potentially large key space for efficiency and lack of clutter.</p>
388
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
389
    <h4>Name</h4>
390
    POST /gdp/v1/kv &mdash; add data to key-value store<br>
391
    <h4>Description</h4>
392
    <p>There is a single key-value store.&nbsp; All data must be formatted as
393
      JSON objects.&nbsp; POST adds all of the names inside the content to the
394
      KV store.&nbsp; For example a POST with the contents { "a": 1, "b": 2 }
395
      adds two values to the store.&nbsp; A subsequent POST with contents { "a":
396
      3, "c": 4 } updates the value of a, adds a new value c, and leaves b
397
      unchanged.</p>
398
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
399
    <h4>Name</h4>
400
    <p>GET /gdp/v1/kv/&lt;key&gt;<br>
401
    </p>
402
    <h4>Description</h4>
403
    <p>Returns the value of &lt;key&gt; in JSON notation.<br>
404
    </p>
405
    <hr size="2" width="100%">
406
    <p><br>
407
    </p>
408
    <a id="Summary"><h2> 4 Summary</h2></a>
409
    <p>This is just a quick recap of the material presented above.&nbsp; All
410
      URLs begin with "<code>/gdp/v1/</code>".<br>
411
    </p>
412
    <table border="1" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="2" width="100%">
413
      <tbody>
414
        <tr>
415
          <td valign="top"><H4>Scope</H4>
416
          </td>
417
          <td valign="top"><H3>Method</H3>
418
          </td>
419
          <td valign="top"><H3>URI Path</H3>
420
          </td>
421
          <td valign="top"><H3>Description</H3>
422
          </td>
423
        </tr>
424
        <tr>
425
          <td valign="top">GDP<br>
426
          </td>
427
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
428
          </td>
429
          <td valign="top">gcl<br>
430
          </td>
431
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">Lists existing GCLs</span>&nbsp;<br>[405 Method Not Allowed]<br>
432
          </td>
433
        </tr>
434
        <tr>
435
          <td valign="top">GDP<br>
436
          </td>
437
          <td valign="top">POST<br>
438
          </td>
439
          <td valign="top">gcl<br>
440
          </td>
441
          <td valign="top">Create new GCL with random name<br>
442
          </td>
443
        </tr>
444
        <tr>
445
          <td valign="top">GDP<br>
446
          </td>
447
          <td valign="top">PUT<br>
448
          </td>
449
          <td valign="top">gcl<br>
450
          </td>
451
          <td valign="top">Create new GCL with specified name<br>
452
          </td>
453
        </tr>
454
        <tr>
455
          <td valign="top">GDP<br>
456
          </td>
457
          <td valign="top">DELETE<br>
458
          </td>
459
          <td valign="top">gcl<br>
460
          </td>
461
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">Delete GCL</span><br>[405 Method Not Allowed]<br>
462
          </td>
463
        </tr>
464
        <tr>
465
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
466
          </td>
467
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
468
          </td>
469
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;<br>
470
          </td>
471
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">GCL &lt;id&gt; read metadata</span><br>[405 Method Not Allowed]<br>
472
          </td>
473
        </tr>
474
        <tr>
475
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
476
          </td>
477
          <td valign="top">POST</td>
478
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;<br>
479
          </td>
480
          <td valign="top">GCL &lt;id&gt; append record<br>
481
          </td>
482
        </tr>
483
        <tr>
484
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
485
          </td>
486
          <td valign="top">PUT<br>
487
          </td>
488
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;?recno=&lt;#&gt;<br>
489
          </td>
490
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">GCL &lt;id&gt; append record at recno or report conflict</span>&nbsp;<br>[405 Method Not Allowed]<br>
491
          </td>
492
        </tr>
493
        <tr>
494
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
495
          </td>
496
          <td valign="top">DELETE<br>
497
          </td>
498
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;<br>
499
          </td>
500
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">GCL  &lt;id&gt; delete record</span><br>Deprecated: GCL is append-only by design<br>
501
          </td>
502
        </tr>
503
        <tr>
504
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
505
          </td>
506
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
507
          </td>
508
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;?recno=&lt;#&gt;<br>
509
          </td>
510
          <td valign="top">GCL &lt;id&gt; read record at recno<br>(returns raw data)<br>
511
          </td>
512
        </tr>
513
        <tr>
514
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
515
          </td>
516
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
517
          </td>
518
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;?recno=&lt;#&gt;&amp;nrecs=&lt;#&gt;<br>
519
          </td>
520
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">GCL  &lt;id&gt; read nrecs records starting from recno</span><br>Deprecated: violates REST standard (nrecs value is not limited). Use websocket API instead.<br>
521
          </td>
522
        </tr>
523
        <tr>
524
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
525
          </td>
526
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
527
          </td>
528
          <td valign="top">gcl/&lt;id&gt;?timeout=&lt;#&gt;<br>
529
          </td>
530
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">Wait for new data to appear on GCL</span><br>Deprecated: violates REST standard (subscription). Use websocket API instead.<br>
531
          </td>
532
        </tr>
533
        <tr>
534
          <td valign="top">GCL<br>
535
          </td>
536
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
537
          </td>
538
          <td valign="top">put/gcl/&lt;id&gt;?&lt;arguments&gt;<br>
539
          </td>
540
          <td valign="top"><span style="text-decoration: line-through;">Add JSON record to GCL &lt;id&gt;</span><br>Deprecated: violates REST standard (arguments are not limited).<br>
541
          </td>
542
        </tr>
543
        <tr>
544
          <td valign="top">RESTful Server<br>
545
          </td>
546
          <td valign="top">POST<br>
547
          </td>
548
          <td valign="top">kv<br>
549
          </td>
550
          <td valign="top">Add JSON information to key-value store<br>
551
          </td>
552
        </tr>
553
        <tr>
554
          <td valign="top">RESTful Server<br>
555
          </td>
556
          <td valign="top">GET<br>
557
          </td>
558
          <td valign="top">kv/&lt;key&gt;<br>
559
          </td>
560
          <td valign="top">Return JSON information associated with &lt;key&gt;
561
            in the key-value store<br>
562
          </td>
563
        </tr>
564
      </tbody>
565
    </table>
566
    <p><br>
567
    </p>
568
    <h2>4 Unresolved Issues</h2>
569
    <p>Do subscriptions wait until all data is ready to return, or does it
570
      return immediately as soon as any data appears?</p>
571
        <p>How are signatures on POST methods handled?</p></p>
572
        <h2> </h2>
573
</body></html>